Do Nonprofit Hospitals Exercise Market Power?
نویسندگان
چکیده
Several theories of nonprofit hospital behavior predict that nonprofit hospitals behave in the consumer interest and thus do not exercise market power. If these theories are correct, then antitrust enforcement of hospital mergers should be restricted only to those markets in which a nonprofit hospital cannot offset anticompetitive behavior by for-profit hospitals. In this paper, we measure a hospital’s market power using two alternative measures. The first is the HHI for a county; the second is the distance from a hospital to its closest competitor. For both measures, we find that nonprofit hospitals set higher prices when they have more market power.
منابع مشابه
How do nonprofits respond to negative wealth shocks The impact of the 2008 stock market collapse on hospitals
The theory of cost shifting posits that nonprofit firms “share the pain” of negative financial shocks with their stakeholders, for example, by raising prices. We examine how nonprofit hospitals responded to the sharp reductions in their assets caused by the 2008 stock market collapse. The average hospital did not raise prices, but hospitals with substantial market power did cost shift in this w...
متن کاملHospital ownership and medical services: market mix, spillover effects, and nonprofit objectives.
Hospitals operate in markets with varied demographic, competitive, and ownership characteristics, yet research on ownership tends to examine hospitals in isolation. Here we examine three hospital ownership types -- nonprofit, for-profit, and government -- and their spillover effects. We estimate the effects of for-profit market share in two ways, on the provision of medical services and on oper...
متن کاملAntitrust Treatment of Nonprofits: Should Hospitals Receive Special Care?
Nonprofit hospitals receive favorable tax treatment in exchange for providing socially beneficial activities. Extending this rationale suggests that nonprofit hospital mergers should be evaluated differently than mergers of for-profit hospitals because suppression of competition may also allow nonprofits to cross-subsidize care for the poor. Using detailed California data, we find no evidence t...
متن کاملThe Effect of Tax Exemption on the Market Share of Nonprofit Hospitals
It has been hypothesized that higher tax rates lead to a larger market share for nonprofit hospitals, given their tax exempt status. However, existing cross-sectional studies offer little empirical support for the hypothesis. We reexamine this issue using a panel data set and find that higher state corporate income and local property tax rates lead to a greater market share for nonprofit hospit...
متن کاملDo nonprofit hospitals pay their way?
Using 1988 and 1991 data from nonprofit voluntary hospitals in California, we find that the vast majority of nonprofit hospitals provide community dividends in excess of the tax subsidies they receive. However, nearly 20 percent of nonprofit hospitals do not meet this standard. Further, those hospitals that do not meet the standard tend to not meet the standard over time. We recommend more expl...
متن کامل